(407) 757-2883
Business Valuations & Collaborative Cases: Can the financial neutral in a collaborative case do the business valuation for the same case?
Guest Entry By: Adam T. Magill, MBA, AVA, CBA, CFFA
The financial professional in a collaborative case serves as a joint expert for both parties in a neutral capacity. The role is to aid in the organization of all documentation required for the case and to advise on proposed equitable distribution, standards of living, etc. For a case involving a privately-held business, is an outside business valuation expert required?
Obviously, if the financial professional is not credentialed to complete one, then the need most certainly exists if the parties cannot agree separately to a value.
However, can the financial professional complete one and maintain his/her neutrality? Business valuation standards require that all valuations be completed in an unbiased, professional manner and are not skewed by financial, personal, or professional partiality. As such, yes, the financial professional can complete the valuation as well.
But what if one client doesn’t like the number? Education is key to making sure that both parties understand how the valuation was derived and the methodology employed. The collaborative process applies to the valuation just as it applies to every part of the case. Information is gathered; options are explored. One option is for the client to seek an alternate valuation or critique if he/she does not agree, as an example.
If at any time the financial professional feels he/she has lost the trust or appearance of neutrality, then an outside opinion should be sought to maintain the neutrality first and foremost. But with the proper implementation of the collaborative process and the valuation standards, the need for outside assistance will most likely be minimal.
